Log in as a…



We’ve partnered with CREA to help improve your member experience and give your information the best security possible.

You will be returned to OREA once you have successfully logged in.

Login as a Member

We can help

Legal Beat: Make sure clients understand BRA before signing

May 2017

Legal Beat: Make sure clients understand BRA before signing

April 24, 2017

by Merv Burgard

Legal beat

In this case, the buyer clients said they did not understand what they were signing when they were presented with a Buyer Representation Agreement (BRA).

A salesperson and his broker of record gave confusing evidence as to whether the BRA was explained to these first-time home buyers. This was the salesperson’s second deal and everyone in the transaction spoke English and Urdu. The brokerage sued for overholding commission and lost.

In his 21-page decision, the Brampton small claims court judge referred to the usual issues of credibility and Non Est Factum [a lack of understanding], as noted in several prior decisions.

Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc. v Saleem 2016 CanLII 30103 (ON SCSM)

New real estate app to develop business plan
Video tutorials explain forms


Although not necessary to his ruling, the judge in this case offered suggestions to real estate salespeople. He advised registrants on the handling and explanation of the BRA to consumers who may not have English as a first language and/or to consumers who are inexperienced in real estate transactions.

“I will now comment by way of obiter dictum [a side comment], what agents and their brokerages should do if they are to avoid the defence of Non Est Factum when it comes to execution and delivery of buyer representation agreements. They must, at a minimum, ensure they do the following:

a) Explain in very clear terms that the representation agreement is different in form and purpose from any offer to purchase that might be discussed when the representation agreement is tabled;

  • Sign the representation agreement in an office environment, not in, or on, a car;
  • Explain to the buyer that the representation agreement is how the agent gets paid for their services;
  • Explain in the buyer’s native tongue, (where necessary), the main terms of the agreement, namely the term, commission rate, exclusive nature of their representation, and draw the buyer’s attention to the nature and purpose of the holdover provision;
  • Make it absolutely clear to the buyer that, under the holdover provision, their obligations under the representation agreement will continue, even if the relationship between agent and buyer breaks down, and
  • Physically separate, and distinguish, the representation agreement from any offer to purchase, if successive signature of both cannot be avoided.
  • Mervin Burgard Q.C.

    To my mind, if these simple steps are taken, it would make enforcement of buyer representation agreements much easier. It is not enough to rely upon the “acknowledgment” provision toward the end of these agreements as evidence of the buyer’s understanding and acceptance thereof. This provision itself has to be explained if reliance thereon is sought.”

    Is that what happens with all of your Representation Agreements with buyers and sellers? This might make a good topic for discussion at your next office meeting.

    Merv Burgard, Q.C.

    May EDGE
    Download a text-only PDF of the May EDGE
    To receive The EDGE direct to your inbox update your details now

    Download a Text-only PDF of the May Realtor® Edge Newsletter

    Download Now

    Don't miss an issue subscribe to the Realtor® Edge Newsletter

    Ray Ferris

    I wouldn’t have become president of OREA if it wasn’t for the top-notch training developed by OREA’s Centre for Leadership Development.

    More May Realtor® Edge Articles


    Real estate teams: Are they right for you?

    Working as a part of a real estate team has pros and cons. Two Ontario REALTORS® discuss why it’s the right choice for them.

    Read More

    Seven tips to show your professionalism

    Here are seven ways to demonstrate professionalism to real estate colleagues.

    Read More

    Master the offer process: Join seminar

    Handling offers is an exciting but stressful part of real estate. Take part in a seminar to learn about different forms that can help you master the process.

    Read More
    To MP Survey
    OREA Contract